OMEdit: Undo stack is cleared when the model is saved in TextView

[Jan Kokert]

Since 90da68c/OMEdit the undo stack is cleared when the model is saved. This is quite bothersome and should be fixed asap. Thanks!

[Adeel Asghar]

I guess you probably mean saving when you are in the text view with manual changes in the text. If this is the case then it is duplicate of #4344.

[Jan Kokert]

Yes I mean, saving when working in the Text View.
In #4344 you wrote:

when you explicitly change something in the text view and switch back to Diagram/Icon view then we clear the stack

I do not switch back and forth - I just save the model. Internally it might me the same reason but still, it is a different issue.

As I said, the new behavior is really bothersome when I just work in the Text View. I often press [control]+[s] automatically from time to time. And then you can't go back :(
Currently, due to that, OMEdit is not really usable for me and I always have to keep an external copy of my previous work...

Can't you disable the stack of QPlainTextEdit with setUndoRedoEnabled(false) and implement a coherent stack for both graphical and textual changes?

Further, this might be helpful:
​http://www.qtcentre.org/threads/43268-Setting-Text-in-QPlainTextEdit-without-Clearing-Undo-Redo-History

And this (reimplement the slots):

class MyTestEdit : public QPlainTextEdit {
    Q_OBJECT

public slots:
    void redo() { ... }
    void undo() { ... }

};

​http://stackoverflow.com/questions/40346373/how-to-override-undo-redo-in-qplaintextedit

[Adeel Asghar]

Replying to janK:

Yes I mean, saving when working in the Text View.
In #4344 you wrote:

when you explicitly change something in the text view and switch back to Diagram/Icon view then we clear the stack

I do not switch back and forth - I just save the model. Internally it might me the same reason but still, it is a different issue.

Yes, it is same.

As I said, the new behavior is really bothersome when I just work in the Text View. I often press [control]+[s] automatically from time to time. And then you can't go back :(
Currently, due to that, OMEdit is not really usable for me and I always have to keep an external copy of my previous work...

Can't you disable the stack of QPlainTextEdit with setUndoRedoEnabled(false) and implement a coherent stack for both graphical and textual changes?

No. Then I need to keep track of text changes manually which literally means writing your own QPlainTextEdit.

Further, this might be helpful:
​http://www.qtcentre.org/threads/43268-Setting-Text-in-QPlainTextEdit-without-Clearing-Undo-Redo-History

And this (reimplement the slots):

class MyTestEdit : public QPlainTextEdit {
    Q_OBJECT

public slots:
    void redo() { ... }
    void undo() { ... }

};

​http://stackoverflow.com/questions/40346373/how-to-override-undo-redo-in-qplaintextedit

Yeah I have already seen all of these things and they don't really help.

I guess f681e38/OMEdit will fix this ticket but #4344 still remains.

[Jan Kokert]

Reviewing all your commits and reverts it looks like it is actually a very difficult matter... I wish you the best of success to fix it soon :)

[Adeel Asghar]

Yes, it is not easy.
I am closing this ticket since now text view stack is always retained.
The only remaining thing is to keep the diagram stack which is discussed in #4344.

[Jan Kokert]

I confirm that this issue is fixed - Thanks a lot! Now we can work again thith the Nightly Builds :D